Planet Nine Might Not Be Responsible For Bizarre Orbits Of Distant Objects

The mysterious dwarf planet Sedna discovered in 2003.                  NASA  JPL

However, a new study exploring the interaction between icy trans-Neptunian objects sitting in the outer parts of our solar system hints that the collective gravity from these objects, and not Planet Nine, might be responsible for the odd orbits of the detached objects.

But Ann-Marie Madigan, an assistant professor in the Department of Astrophysical and Planetary Sciences at the University of Colorado Boulder, has a different argument. This hypothesized world, dubbed Planet 9, would be approximately 10x the mass of Earth, 2-4x its diameter, and would have an elongated orbit that takes as much as 15,000 years to travel once around the sun. How they got to the outer solar system on their own is an ongoing mystery.

This means Sedna's orbit can transition from being relatively normal to appearing to be detached from our solar system because of a multitude of interactions with the gravity of smaller bodies.

"He came into my office one day and says, 'I'm seeing some really cool stuff here, '" Madigan said.

One theory for its unusual dynamics is that an as-of-yet-unseen ninth planet beyond Neptune may have disturbed the orbits of Sedna and other detached objects.

The skeptics include Madigan and Fleisig, who, along with study co-author Alexander Zderic, a UC Boulder graduate student, think they've found an alternate solution to the weird orbital signatures. Like other such detached objects, Sedna moves sedately through a huge circular orbit that keeps it well away from Neptune and other planets that might otherwise perturb it. The physical mechanism by which these massive minor planets become detached is now unknown.

An artist's impression of the dwarf planet Sedna, some 12.9 billion kilometres (8 billion miles) from the sun, along with a hypothetical moon.

According to the researchers' simulations, the TNOs move like hands on a clock, with the most massive objects moving slowly, like the hour hand, and the smaller ones ticking along quickly, like the minute hand.

"You see a pileup of the orbits of smaller objects to one side of the sun", Fleisig said in the statement, explaining the point when the two hands meet.

'These orbits crash into the bigger body, and what happens is those interactions will change its orbit from an oval shape to a more circular shape'.

Speaking at a meeting of the American Astronomical Society, Jacob Fleisig of the University of Colorado at Boulder presented a tantalizing new bit of research. But because the largest objects are hurled into the most eccentric orbits, they become more hard to find, the researchers said.

These bumper car-like interactions can explain numerous anomalies out there, without needing to invent a huge Planet Nine.

This swarm of asteroids may also be able to mess with the orbits of comets and other asteroids, and under the right conditions (researchers estimate roughly every 30 million years) the rogue asteroid in question will end up on a collision course with Earth.

Well, as it turns out, the new theory that axes Planet Nine might also be tied to the dinosaur extinction.

Related News:

Most liked

Doctor Sees Lump On Woman’s Throat On TV, Saves Her Life
After she emailed the show's producers, he went for tests and was diagnosed with thyroid cancer at the age of 31. Dr Voigt said in a follow-up post. "I've held back some tears".

Philly woman arrested on Wildwood beach speaks out
As officers try to arrest her, she runs away, shouting profanities and telling them not to handcuff her. Dicht said Weinman wasn't looking for trouble and was just trying to enjoy the day with her child.

'A Star is Born' trailer starring Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga
Lady Gaga flaunts her figure Fri, January 5, 2018 Lady Gaga wasn't afraid to bare all when she stepped this rather risqué look. Gaga is performing original songs in the film, which she co-wrote with Cooper and other artists, including Mark Ronson .

Guatemala warns of greater activity after volcano explodes again
Naomi Diaz of the Ciraiz Beauty Academy said they were moved to help because they saw people who had lost everything. A blanket of volcanic ash covered nearby town El Rodeo.

Sasse responds to August Senate recess being canceled
In a statement Tuesday, the majority leader said he wanted to use the recess to confirm nominees and pass appropriations bills. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) canceled August recess due to "the historic obstruction by Senate Democrats".

IHOP teases mysterious name change -- What does IHOB mean?
So until then, sit back, channel your inner IHOP , and brainstorm what the franchise's new name will be like everyone else. Fret not, pancake fans - regardless of their name, the restaurant promises to always deliver on pancakes.

'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' trailer
The visual style on display here is, cliched or not, the closest you could get to bringing a comic book to life on the big screen. In the Marvel comics line, these three are just the tip of an iceberg of infinite alternate Spider-Men.

Kerr upgrades Iguodala's status ahead of Game 3 vs Cavs
Teams and management and the league itself are very supportive of not only community service, of course, but political commentary. Smith also mentioned the Warriors as an option, so if you're looking to get a big payout, perhaps that makes the most sense.

Trump Cancels Eagles White House Visit Over National Anthem Row
The team was expected to be there on Tuesday for an event marking their victory in this year's Super Bowl . "We're united. The smaller group apparently wasn't good enough. "The love and support we've felt all offseason and continue to feel".

Crocodile kills pastor during mass baptism in Ethiopia
A Protestant pastor was killed by a crocodile during a baptism ceremony in an Ethiopian lake, according to the BBC . The Nile Crocodile is said to be responsible for more than 300 attacks in the African continent each year.

Trump may seek separate trade deals with Canada, Mexico
The Trump administration says it wants a big chunk of auto manufacturing to be produced by workers earning around $15 an hour. You'd think that as the current occupant of the White House, Trump might have heard about the incident in some detail.

Microsoft Just Dumped a Data Center Into the Ocean
An undersea cable serves the power the data center needs and transfers data from the data center to the internet on shore. Tech giant Microsoft has sunk a data centre in the sea off Orkney to look at whether it can improve energy efficiency.

Ariya survives rollercoaster round to win US Women's Open
She looked as if she might blow a seven-shot lead over the back nine, the way Palmer did losing to Billy Casper at the 1966 U.S. She's four shots behind Smith, who is at 10-under 134 for the tournament. "She's a spectacular player, obviously", Smith said .

Cristiano Ronaldo joins up with Portugal squad
Real Madrid is trying by all means to keep striker Cristiano Ronaldo , who, apparently, is not eager to pursue a career in Madrid. The Portuguese scored 32 goals during the qualifying campaign, with Cristiano Ronaldo supplying 15 of them.

Aston Villa suspend CEO Keith Wyness after reportedly missing normal tax payment
As a result HMRC has scotched its plans to issue legal proceedings against Villa, via a winding up order in the High Court. A number of players have already left this summer, including John Terry and five loanees.